Warm-white stucco bungalow with a shaded tiled porch, limestone column bases, a deep front lawn, and a spreading live oak.

Old Northeast St. Petersburg: 4th Street North Restaurants, Fall 2026

From mid-October to early December, the Old Northeast has a full social calendar. Almost none of it takes place in a restaurant. Between October 17 and December 6, the Historic Old Northeast Neighborhood Association has six events on its calendar. Two are porch parties at private homes, one is a ride through an alley, and the season ends with a tour of decorated homes.

Meanwhile, the commercial strip along the neighborhood's western edge is between tenants. On 4th Street North, one longtime café has closed, and the report on its closing did not name a replacement. One restaurant is aiming to open in November. A third, larger property has a new owner and no opening date. Two blocks into the neighborhood, the tavern corner at 7th Avenue North still has no confirmed reopening. For roughly the next eight weeks, the porch calendar is the most dependable schedule the neighborhood has.

Three Addresses on 4th Street North, Each on a Different Timeline

Going north to south, the 4th Street changes form a short list. Each address is at a different stage, which is why the strip feels unsettled right now.

1211 4th Street North: closed, with no successor reported. According to St. Pete Rising's July 28 report, The Blend Coffee & Cocktails closed its flagship café here after six years. Owner Stacha Madsen told the outlet the company had "made the difficult decision to consolidate its St. Petersburg operations, which means its original Old Northeast location will be closing," and added, "this isn't goodbye." The Blend is still open in St. Pete at its Magnolia Heights café, 3001 16th Street North, and at its drive-thru at 2760 34th Street North. The 4th Street café opened in early 2020, shortly after the company's first local location in the Tampa Bay Times building downtown. The closure report did not name a next tenant for the space.

1040 4th Street North: aiming to open by mid-November. St. Pete Rising reported on September 21 that Carúpano Kitchen plans to open its first brick-and-mortar restaurant here. It is a 1,070-square-foot space that most recently held a catering kitchen and, before that, Urban Canning Company. Andrea Osorio started Carúpano at Foodie Labs, a commercial kitchen incubator in the Warehouse Arts District, in 2025 with her mother, Diann Cedeño, and her wife, Lauren Haley. The menu is built around arepas, Venezuelan corn cakes that are grilled or fried, split, and filled with meats, cheeses, seafood, or vegetables. Empanadas are the other draw. The new location keeps the core recipes and adds lighter options for lunch. "It'll just be an elevated version that caters to this new location," Osorio told St. Pete Rising. The Foodie Labs pop-up is expected to close once the 4th Street restaurant opens.

2221 4th Street North: new owner, no date. For more than 30 years this building was The Melting Pot. Sesh St. Pete followed for a short run. St. Pete Rising reported on October 8 that Pelato, a Brooklyn-Italian restaurant, will be the next tenant. Nashville-based Avenue T Hospitality Group bought the 7,630-square-foot property for $4 million, in a deed recorded October 7. The group runs Pelato locations in Nashville, Franklin, and Charleston. Chef Anthony Scotto and his wife, Teresa, created the concept after moving from New York to Nashville in 2022. The menu is designed for sharing. It includes potato croquettes made from Teresa's mother's recipe, panelle with whipped ricotta, Brooklyn-style fried calamari, chicken scarpariello, and house-made pastas such as radiatori vodka and bucatini cacio e pepe. The property has an indoor-outdoor bar facing 4th Street North, a patio, and a large main dining room built around a brick chimney. No opening date has been announced.

Together, these three addresses show the pattern. The space with no reported successor is the one that served the morning crowd. The most likely November arrival is a 1,070-square-foot counter for lunch. The biggest bet is a 7,630-square-foot dining room that has a deed and a menu but no date.

The Corner Inside the Neighborhood Is Still Waiting Too

The 4th Street changes are on the edge of the neighborhood. The bigger gap is at 201 7th Avenue North. Old Northeast Tavern and Old Northeast Pizza have been owned by Robert Wareham and Mark Brindle since 2008. When St. Pete Rising reported on June 11, both were still closed after nearly two years of renovation. A plan to reopen in summer 2025 was held up by permitting, and the owners then expected to reopen "later this year." Under the plan described then, the tavern and the pizzeria would each keep their own menu and share an expanded dining room. Tavern burgers, fries, and cocktails were possible additions.

We have not found a confirmed reopening date published since that June report. As of October 11, "later this year" leaves less than three months. Until the owners announce a date, the corner should be treated as still closed.

Porch Season, With the Storefront Dates Added

Laying the association's calendar next to the storefront timelines shows how little the two overlap. The porch season will be nearly over before most of the new commercial pieces can open.

Date What Where
Saturday, Oct. 17, 7:30 p.m. Old Northeast Night at the Rowdies, a HONNA fundraiser Al Lang Stadium
Thursday, Oct. 29, 6:30 to 8 p.m. Share and Scare Ride A neighborhood alley; details on the HONNA event page
Friday, Oct. 30, 7:30 to 10 p.m. "Come as You Aren't" Halloween Porch Party A host home in the neighborhood
First week of November Candlelight Tour tickets go on sale HONNA
Monday, Nov. 16 HONNA quarterly meeting Westminster Palms
By mid-November Carúpano Kitchen's target opening 1040 4th Street North
Friday, Nov. 20, 7:30 to 10 p.m. November Porch Party A host home in the neighborhood
Sunday, Dec. 6, 3 to 8 p.m. Candlelight Tour of Homes Throughout the neighborhood
No date announced Pelato 2221 4th Street North
No confirmed date Old Northeast Tavern and Old Northeast Pizza 201 7th Avenue North

The two Halloween events are tied to the same host home. The Share and Scare Ride starts in the alley behind it on Thursday evening, and the porch party there begins at 7:30 the next night. HONNA's event pages list the details. The Rowdies night is the only October event held outside the neighborhood, and the money it raises goes back to the association.

Carúpano's mid-November target falls between the quarterly meeting on November 16 and the November Porch Party on November 20. If it opens on schedule, it will be the first new 4th Street restaurant of the season to open its doors, and it will be open before the last porch party of the year. St. Pete Rising reported mid-November as a target, not a confirmed opening day.

December 6 Is the Date With the Most Certainty

The Candlelight Tour of Homes is the one fixed point at the end of the season. It runs Sunday, December 6, from 3 to 8 p.m. The association describes decorated homes, a hospitality tent with local food and drinks, and seasonal music. Tickets are expected to go on sale the first week of November, about three weeks from today and roughly four weeks before the tour.

On the commercial side, December 6 is also about when the "later this year" estimate for the tavern runs out of time. The June report gave no month, so the tour date is not a deadline for the owners. It is simply the last major neighborhood event of 2026, and the tavern's status should be clearer by then.

On 4th Street North, the three addresses will still be on different timelines once the season ends. 1211 has no reported successor, 1040 may be serving lunch, and 2221 will have a menu, an owner, and a brick chimney but still no posted opening date.

When a commercial corner changes hands, it also changes how the blocks around it feel and how they are valued. The team at The Orns Solution follows these changes on 4th Street North and in the Old Northeast address by address. If you're wondering how these changes affect your own block, contact us for a straightforward local opinion.

Work With Us

If you’re looking to buy or sell a home on or near the West Coast of Florida, let us help you! Your satisfaction is our top priority. For a stress-free experience, we're here every step of the way. Contact us today to get started.

Follow Us on Instagram